Theses
An experiment in controversy
by Kira Shishkin
The spirit

From 2017, Kira Shishkin collected, designed, and tested statements that reliably trigger strong reactions from their readers. This rage bait collection eventually came to be exhibited as Theses, and led to a collaboration with Jenny Holzer on You Be My Ally in 2020.
Kira observed how American culture was becoming increasingly fearful of intellectual discomfort, and incapable of controversy. He picked the exhibition environment as the channel for the message, betting that art gives us permission to feel things we typically wouldn't. Kira's goal was to reintroduce and renormalize disagreement in a zeitgeist that forcefully denied its existence.
Visitors would stroll around the space with the walls covered in quotes. The Theses were “ubiquitous and inescapable,” befitting the spirit they represented. The exhibit was a visibly social experience, as different visitors observed each other pause, react, and dwell on different sections, indirectly communicating and setting expectations for the later viewer.
Presented here is a selection of Theses from the original exhibit.
The theses
- “some people always feel used”
- “failure shouldn’t be a surprise”
- “never eat unless you are hungry”
- “you can only build as you climb”
- “failure is only sweet when temporary”
- “obsession with balance is a sin”
- “balance is a mature indulgence”
- “suicide is a childish fantasy”
- “constant competition is unhealthy”
- “academia is a distraction from real life”
- “math has no spirit”
- “speaking in absolutes is sinful”
- “freedom fades when unexercised”
- “simplicity is sexy”
- “attachment to land is irrational”
- “silence is a luxury”
- “normality is fiction”
- “waiting for life and for death is the same”
- “settlement breeds dissatisfaction”
- “scarcity elicits greed”
- “power is the most addictive drug”
- “unstructured beauty does not exist”
- “those who can’t do — teach”
- “ego is a justifiable indulgence”
- “homosexuality is a positive social construct”
- “patience is an excuse for suffering”
- “pursuit of justice is an excuse for injustice”
- “life without mistakes is a waste”
- “unanimity is a delusional expectation”
- “education is a form of interactive entertainment”
- “throughout life one should meet as many people as one can remember”
- “restraint is a euphemism for fear”
- “skepticism is sexy”
- “comfortable chains are the most difficult to break”
- “accepting your childishness is an exercise in maturity”
- “humility is the highest order of security”
- “defeat is nothing more, but a sacrifice of standards”
- “obsession is characterized by impermanence”
- “ambition is only for the strong”
- “one must never permit morality to inhibit experimentation”
- “idleness is inherently evil”
- “the expectation of loyalty is ironic”
- “the profession of soldier and whore is a similar one”
- “mandatory military service is incompatible with liberty”
- “envy is contagious”
- “stubbornness is a form of fear”
- “happiness leads to patience, not the other way around”
- “every moment not spent in pleasure is wasted”
- “one cannot rest when there are wheels to invent”
- “most art does not deserve its praise”
- “imitation is the blueprint for innovation”
- “civilization is hypocritical savagery”
- “loving your partner is more important than loving your children”
- “knowledge is as much a luxury as is freedom”
- “all beauty can only be conveyed briefly”
- “a love won is a love lost”
- “critique is the highest form of flattery”
- “academia is the longest route from naivete to ignorance”
- “love is a good choice”
- “doubt is a form of love”
- “true learning is painful”
- “the root of all pain is desire”
- “a beautiful death is worth living for”
- “all writing is dogmatism”
- “luxury is criminal”
- “chivalry is sexist”
- “insecurity is a prerequisite of hate”
- “partnership is a denial of competition”
- “alienation cultivates civility”
- “you are inevitably at the center of life”
- “love is incompatible with pride”
- “you are as old as the people that surround you”
- “incident is an unrecognized necessity”
- “all art is propaganda”
- “manipulation is incompatible with respect”
- “predestination is incompatible with morality”
- “sacrifice is charming”
- “suffering warrants credibility”
- “envy is flattering”
- “all love is timed”
- “age doesn't warrant respect”
- “with patience there can be no lust”
- “self-expression is a divine exercise”
- “anything can be art, almost none of it is”
- “when you live to the fullest you age faster”
- “death is not always a defeat”
- “permanence is terrifying”
- “justice is arbitrary”
- “environmentalism is arrogant”
- “we owe nothing to future generations”
- “the woman teaches the man how to be a father”
- “there is no wrong way to get inspired”
- “guilt is an indulgence of the inexperienced”
- “hate is a poor critic”